About How It Works Coverage FAQ Book a Call Become an Agent Take the Scorecard
About Keith

I sell life insurance becauseI've seen what happens without it.

I'm Keith Spencer, the founder of Spencer Life Agency. Before I ever sold a life insurance policy, I spent years as a pastor. I've sat with families through some of the hardest days of their lives. I've been there for hospital rooms, funerals, and the days afterward when everyone else goes home and a family is left trying to figure out what comes next. But I've also experienced loss from the other side. Twice, my own family lost someone without life insurance in place. Both times, while we were grieving, we also had to figure out how to pay for everything that came with the loss. Those experiences are a big part of why I do what I do today.

Thirty minutes, on Zoom or the phone.

Keith Spencer, Spencer Life Agency
Keith SpencerLicensed Life Insurance Agent
Keith and Bethany Spencer
Why this is personal

I've seen both sides of this, in my own family.

My nephew Preston was killed in a mass shooting in Wichita. There was no warning and no time to prepare. Our family was suddenly trying to process something unimaginable while also dealing with all of the practical things that come after someone dies. Preston didn't have life insurance. Others set up a GoFundMe to help with expenses and support the people he left behind, and I took on the job of pushing it out through the media, trying to get as many eyes on it as I could. My great-nephew also died when he was only ten years old, and once again there wasn't coverage in place. Once again, our family found ourselves relying on other people for financial help while we were grieving. That stayed with me. I come from a proud family. We're pastors and helpers, usually the people bringing meals, raising money, and sitting in hospital rooms for someone else. Suddenly we were the ones who needed help. There's nothing wrong with needing people, and community showed up for us in a way I'm deeply grateful for. But I also know now that some financial burdens can be prepared for ahead of time, and if I can help another family do that, I want to.

Twice, my family had to ask others for help to bury someone we loved.

But I've also seen what it looks like when a family is ready. When my dad passed away, he had life insurance in place. It meant my mom could stay in the house I grew up in until she was ready to sell it, on her own timeline, instead of being pushed into big decisions in the middle of her grief. Same family, both sides of the same coin.

I watched that same kind of breathing room change everything for my wife. Bethany lost her first husband to cancer. She became a widow with five kids and had to figure out how to build a life she never expected to be living. Her husband had life insurance. It couldn't change what happened or make their grief easier, but it meant that in the middle of everything, Bethany didn't also have to immediately worry about losing their home or how she was going to provide for their kids. She had time to make decisions. She had options. She had some financial breathing room while their family grieved and slowly began figuring out what came next. I've now seen what both of those experiences look like: a family grieving while scrambling to cover the costs of a death, and a grieving family that had financial breathing room. That's why this work became personal for me long before it became a business.

Why I do this

What I want every family to know is simple: if something happened to you, would the people you love have the financial room they need to keep going? You don't have to know the answer before we talk. That's what I'm here to help you figure out.

Keith Spencer · Father of five

Why Spencer Life Agency

Licensed, independent, and working for your family.

I'm not here to talk you into a policy. I'm an independent life insurance agent, which means I can look at coverage from multiple insurance companies instead of trying to make one company's products work for everyone. But honestly, that's not the part I care most about. What matters to me is that you understand what you're buying and why. I'll help you look at what you already have, figure out what your family may actually need, and decide whether anything should change. Sometimes that means helping someone find a new policy. Sometimes it means telling them the policy they already have is a good one and they should keep it. And sometimes it means deciding that now isn't the right time to do anything at all. I'd rather you leave our conversation understanding your coverage than buy something from me because you felt pressured.

1

Licensed

Life, Accident & Health insurance producer. Resident state: Indiana. NPN 21442482, licensed across multiple states.

2

Independent

I work with 12+ highly rated carriers, so I compare across them to find what fits your family instead of selling one company's product.

3

More than policies

Ordained minister, and licensed to offer fixed and fixed indexed annuities for families thinking about retirement.

And since people sometimes wonder, here's how I get paid. There's no fee to meet with me. If you decide to purchase a policy, the insurance company pays me a commission. You don't pay me separately for helping you compare options or walk through your coverage. I think you deserve to know that upfront.

Keith Spencer is a licensed life insurance agent. Licensing and product availability vary by state. Connect to confirm availability in your state.

A longtime friend

His character, integrity, and dedication to the people in his life are second to none. He is loyal, dependable, and always willing to step up when someone needs him. Keith leads by example, treats others with respect, and can be counted on no matter the circumstances.

Thom Sliney · Longtime friend, owner of DJ TJ

Where to start

Not sure where your family stands?

That's a good place to start. Take our free Life Insurance Scorecard and get a clearer picture of what you already have and whether there's anything worth a closer look.

Take the Free Scorecard →

Already know you'd rather talk to someone? Talk With Keith

Keith Spencer Keith Spencer · Licensed independent agent, NPN 21442482
Former pastor and father of five. I've sat with families on the hardest day of their lives.